Sheikh Jarah: Jews and Arabs Refuse to be Enemies

Jews and Arabs Refuse to be Enemies

On New Year’s Day, our very first day in Jerusalem, we went to the center of the city to get cellphones.  While we were in the cellphone store, we heard the banging of drums and people chanting.  My daughter asked  what was happening.  We went outside and saw about about 75-100 people marching down the pedestrian mall with banners and signs protesting the eviction of three Palestinian families from Sheikh Jarah whose four houses are now occupied by Jewish settlers.

Their dispossession is part of an effort by the Israeli authorities to settle Jews in the midst of Palestinian neighborhoods: Silwan, Ras el Amud, Sheikh Jarah and others.  These actions, along with home demolitions, denial of residency rights, the unequal distribution of municipal services, are all designed to make it difficult for Palestinians to live in Jerusalem and encourage them to leave.   The goal of these discriminatory practices is to deal with  “the demographic issue,” a racist formulation term freely by liberal Jewish and Israeli groups, that there are too many Palestinians compared to Jews and that their rate of growth exceeds that of the Jewish population.   These efforts to restrict the growth of the Palestinian population in Jerusalem complements the building of vast new Jewish neighborhoods around Jerusalem (Gilo, French Hill, Givat Zeev, Har Homa and others) and according privileges and benefits to Jews who make aliya, immigrate to Israel.

March from West Jerusalem to Sheikh Jarah

The protesters were marching from HaMashbir, the main department store in the center of Jerusalem, to Sheikh Jarah in East Jerusalem.  I was inspired by their courage.  They were well organized and their action brought  the reality of the dispossession in Sheikh Jarah in East (Arab) Jerusalem into the centre of (Jewish) city.  The pedestrian mall (midrochov)  is always bustling with people, Israelis, and many American tourists and young people on Birthright and other such trips, having a great time in Israel, blissfully  unaware of the discrimination and the ethnic privilege that allows us and them to enjoy the stores, restaurants and coffee shops of the Jewish city.

Police checkpoint at entrance to Sheikh Jarah
Police checkpoint at entrance to Sheikh Jarah

It is four weeks since this experience on our first day in Jerusalem but since then the protesters have continued their weekly protest.   They are no longer allowed to march through the city as the Jerusalem police have rejected their request for a permit.  Their protest, confined to an area on the outskirts of  Sheikh Jarah, is legal as long as there are no speeches, as the police not only deny them a right to march through the city but also deny their application for a permit for a legal protest.  The issue now is not only the forced eviction of Palestinian families but also the right to free speech.

At the weekly protest two weeks ago, the police arrested over 20 protesters, including the executive director of the Association of Civil Rights in Israel, and last week they arrested some 20 protesters.  Thus hundreds of Israeli police are deployed to protect  settler families, who, with the full support of the State, have dispossessed three Palestinian families, creating fear and insecurity in the entire neighborhood.  In addition, the police deny the Palestinian residents of the town and even Jewish Israelis a permit to hold a demonstration in the neighborhood  and arrest those who assemble on the outskirts of the neighborhood in perfectly legal expression of free speech!

Protesters and Police
Protesters and Police

I, like many others, shocked by the arrests of protesters the previous week attended the protest last week.  The protest was the largest so far and a few of the leaders of mainstream Zionist left: Yossi Sarid, Avrum Burg, Moshe Halberthal and others, were at the event.  Jeremiah Haber wrote an  interesting blog post (read the comments as well) suggesting that Sheikh Jarah may mark the rebirth of the Zionist left protest movement.   A Palestinian (Israeli Arab) member of the Knesset was the only Knesset member  present.

The core of the issue in Sheikh Jarah is the same as other realities that I described in my recent posts on Hebron and the illegal outpost.  Israel, as a country, is a state that privileges the rights of Jews over that of non-Jews.  The only real solution is to re-envision Israel as a state of all its citizens, whether within the context of a two state solution or any other political framework.   As many activists here say, “Israel is a democratic state for Jews and Jewish state for Arabs”.  The systematic privileging of Jews over non-Jews is something Jews and Israelis have not yet acknowledged.   There is no such thing as a Jewish and democratic state.  You have to choose between them and Israeli policy is the harsh application of the choice of having a Jewish state rather than a democratic state. Jewish liberals, myself included, would prefer to avoid this challenging discussion but I don’t think we can avoid it any longer.

Lastly, as Yossi Sarid points out in an article in HaAretz, the assertion of the rights of Jews to return to homes that they may have owned before 1948, opens the gates to claims by thousands of Palestinians to their homes in  Katamon, where my family is now living, and in many villages and towns all over Israel.  Unless the discriminatory practice is applied in this instance as well and  it is only Jews who can claim land they owned before 48 and the same rules do not apply to Palestinians!

Sheikh Jarah! Don't Despair! We will end the Occupation! Sheikh Jarah is Palestine!

For detailed background see “Why they are really demonstrating in Sheikh Jarah” on the  Ir Amim website.

If you want to read another report of the demonstration, you will find this article interesting.

This afternoon will be the next weekly demonstration in Sheikh Jarah.


  1. Don says:

    In Florida yesterday President Obama danced around the issue when asked a question about Palestinian civil rights.

  2. Lia Rosen says:

    Dear Brian– I am inspired and grateful for your vivid posts that bring me closer to the search and activism for justice I seek. I sent you a message yesterday to your “home email” to see if we could join you when we come to Jerusalem in February for a month; looks like it will not be hard to connect up! Hope to walk in your footsteps, and with the good education you are providing to so many, here.

    With my blessings and shabbat shalom, Lia

    1. rabbibrian says:

      Thanks for your kind comment and I hope we connect on your visit here.

  3. Martina Lauer says:

    A frank discussion of Israel as a Jewish/democratic state is difficult in North America. People immediately demand a recitation of principle #1 among ‘decent’ people: Israel has the right to exist. As if a criticism of the apartheid structures denies Israel the right to exist.
    Thank you for your insights.

    1. rabbibrian says:

      Thanks for your comment. The charge that criticism of the systematic discrimination in Israel denies Israel’s right to exist is just a way of avoiding dealing with the issue. While I personally no longer think it is possible to have a have a Jewish and democratic state, if Israel continues to define itself a Jewish state, it must accord justice and equality to all it’s citizens regardless of ethnicity or religion. Equality, Human Dignity and Justice is what Judaism is all about. What does it mean to be a Jewish state, if not a state that embodies these values?

  4. Reb Barry says:

    I was out there yesterday, blogged about it at:

  5. Uri ZACKHEM says:

    Dear Rabbi Brian,
    Here are the pics from a week before last Friday:

    מסתערים קדימה ודוחפים את ההמון

    You can see yourself in a couple of pics there.
    Take care,

    1. rabbibrian says:

      Thanks so much, Uri.

  6. YBD says:

    Jews and Arabs are, unfortunately, enemies. But this is not because of Jews moving into Jewish-owned property in Sheikh Jarrah ACCORDING TO A COURT RULING. Jews and Arabs became enemies when Jews insisted on their historical right to immigrate to Eretz Israel and live in it and to set up a state according to the UN Partition Resolution of November 1947. Even if the court had ruled against the Jews moving into the house, Jews and Arabs would still be enemies, because the Arabs define the situation such. Arabs defined the situation as a war BEFORE 1967 when Jews returned to Sheikh Jarrah and other parts of eastern Jerusalem where the lived before 1948. Arabs view the situation as a war because YOU, RABBI BRIAN are currently residing in Katamon in property that was ARAB BEFORE 1948, NOT because of Sheikh Jarrah. The war started before the Jews moved into Sheikh Jarrah recently, it started before 1967, it started even before the war in 1948 that the Arabs started with the express intention of eradicating the Jewish population of Eretz Israel and which led to the Arabs of Katamon and other places fleeing or being forced out as a result of their agression. I would be most impressed if those like Bernard Avishai who admits he lives in an Arab house in west Jerusalem, instead of demonstrating against Jews living in Jewish property in Sheikh Jarrah , would track down the Arab how owned the house he is now living in and give it back to him. The Arabs would view that as justice, not meaningless demonstrations by “progressive” Jews in Sheikh Jarrah who reside in homes the Arabs view as theirs in western Jerusalem.

  7. Jackie says:

    Thank you for publishing such great posts. This is an amazing blog and one that could go a long way to helping to everyone, not just Israelis.

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s